But does he? If the illegal and unconstitutional actions had been accomplished legally, would they still be considered as having contributed to the greater good?
If they didn't care how he did it, how many families he broke up, how many laws he broke, would a Trump supporter consider that Trump was fulfilling his campaign promise of closing the border? Probably they would.
One of the reasons that it appears that Trump has solved the problem of illegal immigration is that Trump says he has solved the problem of illegal immigration. He throws around statistics that are suspect and often compares apples to oranges. For example, early in his second term he compared the total number of Border Patrol encounters for one month of Biden's term with the average weekly numbers for a month early in his own term. Figures that you seldom see are the comparison of the average number illegal crossings that Biden inherited from Trump's first term with the number that Trump inherited from Biden. Trump walked into a much better scenario than Biden did. Trump also tends to take credit for the actions of others. While it is true that Biden's action on border security came late in his term, and only after tremendous pressure, what we are seeing now is a continuation of the downward trend that began under Biden.
While it's clear that illegal immigration through the southern border is a fraction of what it had been at its peak, what's not clear is why. People who are fleeing poverty and gang violence can be pretty tenacious about getting out of those situations. We haven't increased the number of Border Patrol agents (although the Army and National Guard are patrolling sections of the border) and we haven't yet built Trump's Wall. It's possible that potential illegal immigrants have checked out the political situation here and have decided that it isn't worth the risk. In that case it isn't that the border is more secure, it's just that the millions facing starvation and death think coming here is a worse deal for them. Or maybe the coyotes are just getting more creative. What happens if one day things get so bad that they all think it's worth the risk? The Border Patrol will still be the same size as it was in 2024 and we're back where we started. Personally I think it's suspicious that illegal crossings are supposedly down when one of the main avenues of legal entry, asylum claims, have been virtually eliminated. I would think that cutting off a legal way to come here would increase illegal attempts. Me, I don't trust the numbers; as soon as they start looking bad Trump will fire Noem or whoever tracks that information.
From what I can tell asylum seekers who are turned back are tracked separately from illegal crossings. However, Trump and his people have made no secret that they think asylum claims are a big scam, with those applying for it just parroting the right words in order to bring their drug import business into the U.S. But it's perfectly legal to apply for asylum; denying virtually all cases without due process has nothing to do with controlling illegal immigration, but with ending immigration period. (At least the brown kind) Would Trumpists see this as an accomplishment? No doubt they would. Because it's not just about illegal immigration, if it was, there would be a push for an expanded immigration court system, and a streamlined system for vetting and processing people. But the Trumpists see immigration as diluting the blood of "real" Americans.
This is why the lack of due process as undocumented immigrants, as well as non-citizens who are here legally, are rounded up and sent to Salvadoran prisons, or to countries with which they have no ties, doesn't bother them. They're willing to turn aside as the promise to prioritize ejecting violent criminals is forgotten and otherwise law abiding asylum seekers, green card holders and those under temporary protect status are arrested at immigration hearings or at appointments to renew their green card. They consider the ICE raids an "accomplishment" even though it's not really what Trump said he would do.
To the Trump Cult the ends justify the means.