Thursday, November 19, 2026

Social Security Misconceptions and Ron Johnson's Ponzi Scheme Claims

I can't believe I have to keep doing this. 

Every time the looming shortfall in the Social Security Trust fund makes the news there's a cacophony of voices who believe that the solution is to "pay back the money that they stole". Accompanied by outraged cries of "it's my money! I paid into it". Most of what people think about Social Security is wrong. 

First, you don't "pay into" Social Security. If you have income you are taxed 6.2% (+ 1.45% for Medicare), with your employer paying the same amount. That money is not set aside for your benefit, but goes to pay the benefits of those who are currently receiving Social Security payments. When you retire and begin receiving benefits, that money comes from the people who will be working at that time. Part of the confusion comes the fact that the amount of your benefits is calculated based on what you earned during your working life. The Social Security Administration calculates an average of your highest 35 years of earnings, and comes up with what they call the Average Indexed Monthly Earnings (AIME) to which they apply a formula which yields your monthly benefit amount. Even though your benefit is based on your income, and money came out of your paycheck every month to fund Social Security, those payroll deduction did not directly fund your Social Security benefit. 

Secondly, technically, funds have been borrowed from the Social Security Trust Fund (SSTF), but not in the way many people think. In most years through 2017 the revenue collected through payroll taxes paid by employees and employers exceeded what was being paid in benefits. That excess, the annual surplus, did not just set in a bank account somewhere, or in a Scrooge McDuck vault full of cash, but was required by law to be converted to Special Issue, interest bearing, Treasury Bonds. The SSTF received the bonds, and the U.S. Government General Fund received cash in exchange. That cash was used to partially fund government operations. Before we get all worked up, thinking that this means that Congress, or the president was only able to fund pet projects (like wars) due to this borrowing, let's take a moment to discuss deficit spending.

The U.S. government almost always spends more than it takes in via tax revenue. The difference, the deficit, is funded by borrowing. This doesn't mean that Congress goes to a bank and takes out a loan. No, the Treasury Department issues various forms of bonds, which are bought by individuals, domestic and foreign, and even other governments. The cash that is received from the sale of these bonds finances the deficit. The deficit was going to happen whether the money was borrowed via the Special Issue Bonds from the SSTF or not. Borrowing from the SSTF reduced the amount that had to be borrowed from outside sources. Congress, or the president doesn't need to "raid" the SSTF to finance wars or other projects, they just need to increase the deficit! 

Until 2017, as previously stated, the revenue collected through payroll taxes paid by employees and employers exceeded what was being paid in benefits, and the SSTF balance increased. However, starting in 2018 the benefits paid began to exceed revenue from payroll taxes. In order to make up the difference, some SSTF assets, the aforementioned Treasury bonds were cashed in, the resulting cash being used to make up the difference and pay benefits. This annual redeeming of the Treasury Bonds represents the "paying back what was borrowed" which will continue until all the Special Issue Treasury Bonds are cashed in, thereby depleting the SSTF. 

There is no additional borrowing, "raiding", "stealing" or other transfer of funds from the SSTF that is not accounted for. The projected depletion in 2032 or 2033 does not represent a cash account running out, but the actual asset, the bonds, being sold off to finance SSTF deficits. 

Senator Ron Johnson has recently been calling Social Security a "Ponzi Scheme", and claims that the government has scammed Americans about the program. In Johnson's report he claims that Americans have been convinced that Social Security and the portion that comes from their paychecks that fund it, known as the Federal Insurance Contributions Act — the percentage deducted from a person’s paycheck that helps fund Social Security and Medicare — is a retirement account that grows over time. Johnson, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee for another two months, countered that Americans’ tax dollars aren’t in a "lock box" designed to flourish, but instead that 6.2% from every person’s paycheck goes to pay for other peoples’ benefits. "People often say, ‘Don’t touch Social Security, that’s my money,’" Johnson wrote. "Actually, it’s not." "Your money was spent to pay current beneficiaries or fund other government programs as soon as it was collected from your paycheck. Your future benefits will be paid with the money collected from your sons and daughters working at that time, plus money borrowed from the public now that Social Security is running deficits,"

I won't argue with Johnson that Americans believe those things, but I disagree that the government has been doing the scamming. The information on how Social Security is financed and how benefits are paid is available on government websites as well as in sources like AARP. I do disagree with the statement that I put in italics — Social Security deficits aren't being funded by "borrowing from the public", but by paying back what had been previously been borrowed by the public. I would argue that the misconceptions arise from people's own laziness and refusal to "do the research". I also disagree with Johnson that we should simply scrap the program. Wherever people believe the money came from, or what they think they were entitled to, seniors factored in their Social Security benefits into their retirement planning and post retirement budgeting. Losing 22% of my benefit would be a significant reduction in my standard of living. 

I'm a bit more optimistic that something will be done between now and the depletion of the SSTF now that the incoming Congress will be overwhelmingly composed of Democrats.  Here is a great article laying out a combination of changes that could save Social Security. One way or another something needs to be done.

No comments:

Post a Comment